Explaining the Alec Baldwin Defamation Suit

ELI5: Negligence

Alec Baldwin Law Suit

It appears that Alec Baldwin’s legal troubles are far from over. The actor, who is still dealing with the fallout from the fatal shot on the set of Rust, is now involved in a defamation lawsuit that could force him to pay over 25 million dollars to the plaintiffs. According to news articles, Baldwin is being accused of negligence, defamation, and invasion of privacy for some of his social media posts. This latest Alec Baldwin lawsuit may be a good reminder of the fact that, though we have freedom of speech, it doesn’t mean that we are free from the consequences of our speech.


In August of 2021, 13 United States Marines were killed in a bombing at the Kabul airport in Afghanistan. Among the fallen marines was 20-year-old father-to-be, Rylee McCollum. Alec Baldwin generously donated $5,000 to the family’s GoFundMe account that was set up for Rylee’s widow and his unborn daughter. On January 3rd, Roice McCollum, Rylee’s sister, posted a picture of herself in a “Make America Great Again” hat while attending the January 6th protest. In private messages, Alec Baldwin allegedly called the woman an “insurrectionist” and a “riotor”. Roice allegedly clarified in these messages that she was a peaceful protester and had already been cleared of any wrongdoing by the FBI. After an exchange of messages, Baldwin then, reportedly, publicly reposted Roice’s photo on his social media account and sent her a message: “I reposted your photo. Good luck.” According to the defendant’s legal team, Baldwin’s alleged reposting of the photo resulted in Roice receiving an onslaught of harassment and threats. And, according to the claim, Roice was not the only one affected. Cheyenne, also Rylee’s sister, and Jiennah, Rylee’s widow, were also sent harassing messages and threats as a result of Alec Baldwin’s repost.


A $25 million dollar lawsuit may seem like a bit much. But, given Baldwin’s wealth and status, it’s entirely possible, even likely, that this case could settle out of court for an undisclosed amount. However, since there are no physical damage, many people are wondering why the defendants are asking for such a high sum. Though we can’t say for sure how much each part of the claim is worth, we do know that at least three people are involved: Roice, Cheyenne, and Jiennah. Also, Alec’s alleged claims of them being insurrectionists may have seriously damaged their reputation. Since it’s a defamation case, it’s important to highlight that Roice was never charged with any crime in connection with the January 6th riot, and Cheyenne and Jiennah were not even at Capitol Hill on January 6th. Baldwin’s post may have led people to believe that Royce, Cheyenne, and Jiennah did things they did not actually do, or were a part of a group they were not actually part of. Additionally, they’re asking for compensation for these ladies’ emotional distress. As you can imagine, receiving death threats from people you’ve never met would be extremely distressing since there’s no telling what some of those people are capable of. Since he told Roice, “good luck,” it seems that Alec was likely at least partially aware of the likely ramifications of his social media post.


Alec Baldwin Law Suit

Yes, Baldwin is entitled to freedom of speech. However, many people erroneously believe that freedom of speech means freedom from the consequences of your speech. You have the right to yell “fire” in a crowded theater, threaten others with harm, or swear at your supervisors. However, that doesn’t mean you can’t be arrested for disorderly conduct, making threats, or being fired from your job. Your speech is free, but when it causes others to panic, threatens their safety, or creates a hostile environment on private property, there may be consequences.


Though Americans do have freedom of speech, Alec Baldwin’s alleged actions may actually rise to the level of negligent infliction of emotional distress. Though negligent infliction of emotional distress claims typically involves a pattern of emotionally distressing behavior, if the offense is outrageous enough, a plaintiff may have a claim even after only one incident. Baldwin knew or should have known, that a witch hunt was going to be the result of him reposting Roice’s photo. If the claims of insurrection cause any of the defendants to lose their jobs, Baldwin may be liable for loss of income. It’s also possible that he could be on the hook for loss of earning potential as well if his sharing of the photos and insurrectionist claims cause the women to struggle to find employment. Lastly, if any of Baldwin’s followers make good on their threats, Baldwin himself could be liable if his followers injure the women.


Alec Baldwin Law Suit

At Moxie Law Group, we are incredibly thankful for the brave men and women who have given their lives to serve our beautiful country. At this time, our thoughts are with the families of the 13 United States Marines who were fatally injured in the Kabul bombing in August 2021.

Close up of a quarter and a penny.

Five Ways Insurance Companies Avoid Paying Fair Compensation

by | Jan 23, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

Before we go any further, it’s important to understand how insurance works. When you pay your insurance premium, you’re paying for financial coverage (up to the policy...

Various coins

What If The Insurance Company Is Offering Me a Fair Settlement?

by | Jan 18, 2024 | blog,Car Accident,car accident attorney Utah | 0 Comments

The Insurance Company’s Job Is to Make Money  When you buy insurance, you pay a fee—called a premium—on a regular basis. You pay a premium in exchange for financial...

Boots with tulips sitting on a snowy landscape

Five Safety Precautions to Take This Spring

by | Jan 16, 2024 | Auto Accidents,blog,Educational | 0 Comments

Now that the holiday season is over, spring is right around the corner. But it isn’t here yet, and there’s always the possibility of eight more weeks of winter, so...

Two people jogging while it's still snowy outside

Safety Tips for Your Morning Jog

by | Jan 11, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

If you’ve got the motivation and the determination to go for a jog bright and early, there are surely a lot of people who are jealous of such discipline! However,...

Woman working out at the gym

Premises Liability and the Gym

by | Jan 9, 2024 | blog,Educational,Premises Liability | 0 Comments

If you’re going to the gym, make sure you’re staying safe.  What Is Premises Liability?  Premises liability refers to the liability that property owners have when a...

Man lifting like a lot of weight

Safety Tips for the Gym 

by | Jan 4, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

The new year is here, and many people are heading into 2024 with a personal goal to get healthy. Whether that means shedding a few pounds, or getting that resting heart...

Colorful weights you'd find at a gym

Are We About to See More Ozempic Lawsuits?

by | Jan 2, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

Ozempic has been creating quite a lot of buzz, including talks of lawsuits. Are we about to see more lawsuits in 2024?  What’s Product Liability?  When Utah personal...

Woman walking down the stairs in front of a state capital

Can You Be Sued if You’re Broke?

by | Dec 15, 2023 | Educational | 0 Comments

Some people believe that only rich people get sued—but is that true?  How Lawsuits Work  Before we answer that, we need to back up a bit. When a personal injury claim...

People in a crowd at a concert hall.

Who Could Be Liable for Concert Injuries?

by | Dec 12, 2023 | Educational | 0 Comments

If you sustain injury at a concert, who could be liable for those injuries?  The Concert Stadium  Property owners, whether they own residential or commercial property,...