Another Tesla Lawsuit?

ELI5: Negligence


Tesla Accident Utah

Just recently, charges have been filed against a driver for a car crash in 2019 that took the lives of two people. The family of the victims will be suing both Tesla and the driver of the car. The joint trial for Tesla and the driver of the car is set for sometime in 2023. However, with technology rapidly advancing, we are facing increasing pressure to develop laws and regulations to keep everyone safe now that self-driving cars are on the road. But, since automated cars are so new, the laws surrounding them haven’t quite caught up yet. This brings an interesting question: how much liability do the makers of autonomous cars have?


In Utah, we have modified comparative fault, meaning two people can share fault for an accident. This means that even though the plaintiff is the person who was injured and is filing the claim, the jury may apportion liability across multiple parties, including the plaintiff themself. If, for example, a jury decides that both the defendant and the plaintiff are 50% at fault for the accident, the plaintiff will not be compensated for their injuries. In Utah, a plaintiff cannot recover damages if their liability is equal to, or exceeds, 50%. However, if the jury decides that the plaintiff is 40% liable and the defendant is 60% liable, then the judgment that’s awarded to the plaintiff will be reduced by 40%.


The best answer is maybe. Let’s say that a well-known company manufactures a cleaning solution and, the cleaning solution smells so good, someone decides to drink it. Is the cleaning company responsible for such blatant misuse of their product? Believe it or not, it actually depends. Did the company design the packaging to look similar to consumable products? Did the company design the cleaning solution to taste good? Is the solution an attractive color? Did the company actually advertise that you can drink it? The cleaning company would be much less likely to be found liable for the misuse of their product if they took the right precautions, such as adding labels that warn against consumption.


Tesla Accident Utah

Though the previous example seems like an oversimplification, it is relevant to determining liability in the Tesla lawsuit. When determining Tesla’s liability, the question on the jurors’ minds will likely be whether or not Tesla overrepresented their vehicle’s automatic driving capabilities. Assuming the Tesla lawsuit isn’t settled out of court, the jury will also consider whether or not Tesla’s representation of the vehicle promoted or encouraged a lack of attention while operating the vehicle using the automatic driving features. Tesla can limit their liability by taking precautions such as, encouraging drivers to pay attention while driving, under-representing the car’s capabilities, and continuing to create features to prevent inattentive driving on autopilot.


Marketing defects occur when there are issues in the way a product is marketed. Certain products should come with additional instructions for use and, depending on the product, safety warnings. You likely don’t need instructions or safety warnings for the book you just purchased. However, you may need instructions and safety warnings for your new snow blower. Companies also need to take steps to make sure that the product is advertised in a way that it’s intended purpose is clear. This way, the product doesn’t get used in an unsafe manner or, in a way it wasn’t designed to be used. Using your snow blower to make smoothies may work, but it’s not the snow blower’s intended use and is probably dangerous. When companies don’t provide their customers with the information they need to protect themselves from injuries resulting from the use, or inadvertent misuse of the product, they run the risk of being the defendant in a personal injury case. In the Tesla lawsuit, the jury will need to decide if the vehicle, and all of its capabilities, were marketed accurately. And, that the product came with ample instruction and safety warnings.


Tesla Accident Utah

The driver also likely has some liability here. To begin with, the driver knew or reasonably should have known, that he needed to be paying attention while driving despite the fact that the car does have autopilot capabilities. Legally speaking, this is called foreseeability. When drivers are impaired, they are more likely to be liable for the injuries their negligence causes. Though it does not appear that the driver of the Tesla was driving under the influence, it’s alleged that the crash was preventable, and the driver’s potential lack of attention to the road may have significantly contributed to the accident


Lastly, though personal injury trials—civil trials—are separate from criminal trials, the two are related. Since the driver of the Tesla has been charged with manslaughter, that criminal verdict may influence the civil trial. If the driver is found guilty of manslaughter in a criminal trial, a civil court may see that as a strong indication of guilt in a civil trial. And, even if the driver is not found guilty in a criminal trial, a court may still rule against him in a civil trial. 


Tesla Accident Utah

Tragically, this is not the first time a person has lost their life in an autopilot accident. And, it likely won’t be the last either. As technology develops, self-driving cars will become increasingly more prevalent. Though personal injury attorneys work to get compensation for the injured, nothing can adequately compensate a grieving family for the loss of a loved one. However, there is good news: you can make an impact on car crashes by taking extra precautions to keep Utah’s roads safe.

Person grabbing the steering wheel and driving on a busy road

Car Crash but the Other Driver Drove Away! What Now? 

by | Apr 25, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

Car Crash but the Other Driver Drove Away! What Now?  If this has happened to you, don't panic! Keep reading. First Things First  Make sure that you and all your...

People holding presumably alcoholic beverages up for a toast

Can You Sleep in Your Car if You’re Drunk?  

by | Apr 18, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

Can You Sleep in Your Car if You’re Drunk?   You’ve had a big night partying like it’s 1999 and Y2K is tomorrow—so should you sleep it off in your car? Ideally, no. If...

Fast red sports car

Do You Need to Buy Additional Insurance When Renting a Car? 

by | Apr 16, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

Do You Need to Buy Additional Insurance When Renting a Car?   If you’re renting a car, you’ll probably be offered some “extra insurance”—but do you really need it?...

Bright orange sports car

What Is Rental Coverage, and Should You Consider It? 

by | Apr 11, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

What Is Rental Coverage, and Should You Consider It?  What Is Rental Coverage?  Usually, when people talk about “rental car coverage” they’re talking about one of two...

An elderly man and elderly woman walking down the street together

Do Financially Abused Elderly Have Recourse?

by | Apr 4, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

With the invention of the internet, scams preying upon the elderly have gotten more and more difficult to spot, even as the aging population becomes more familiar with...

Two insurance adjusters reviewing a case

“The Insurance Company Said It Was My Fault, but It Wasn’t!”

by | Mar 19, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

" The Insurance Company Said It Was My Fault, but It Wasn’t! " What should you do now? Keep reading! Who Determines Fault in an Accident?  The insurance companies...

Insurance adjuster and potential client reviewing a document

How Much Insurance Do I Really Need?

by | Mar 14, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

How much insurance do I really need? Is the cheapest plan really the best plan? Do you even need insurance in the first place?  How Does Insurance Work?  Customers pay...

Emergency care provider putting a stretcher into an ambulance

Getting Treatment without Health Insurance 

by | Mar 12, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

Is getting treatment without health insurance even possible? Spoiler alert: DON’T avoid treatment just because you don’t have insurance!  Problems with Avoiding...

Close up of a quarter and a penny.

Five Ways Insurance Companies Avoid Paying Fair Compensation

by | Jan 23, 2024 | Educational | 0 Comments

Before we go any further, it’s important to understand how insurance works. When you pay your insurance premium, you’re paying for financial coverage (up to the policy...