Who’s Liable in a Bar Fight?

ELI5: Negligence

St. Patrick’s Day is a day known for celebrating and grabbing a beer, but what happens if things get out of hand at the bar? Is there anything you can do if you were in a St. Patrick’s Day bar fight?  Maybe you’re wondering if you can sue the owner of the bar for allowing the bar fight to happen in the first place. After all, suing the owner of the bar seems like a better idea than suing your opponent, assuming your opponent doesn’t have enough money to compensate you for your injuries.While it’s not impossible, unfortunately, even if you were seriously injured in a bar fight, it may be difficult to get compensation, both from the bar owner, and from the other person involved with the fight.

Premises Liability – Bar Fight Lawyer

Under premises liability, property owners can be held responsible for the injuries guests sustain on the property. Usually, this happens when the property owner failed to remove hazards from the property, or take reasonable precautions to ensure that guests did not become injured due to the property conditions. Premises liability applies to both residential and commercial properties.

So bar owners are generally responsible for removing hazardous conditions from the bar in order to keep their patrons safe. If a guest is being obnoxious, or causing problems, they may need to be removed from the bar in order to protect the other patrons.

Duty

In order to prove that a bar owner was negligent, a personal injury attorney would need to prove that they had a duty, or legal obligation, to take precautions in order to prevent injury. To put that into context, in a premises liability claim a bar owner likely has a duty to remove unsafe conditions from their property, including guests who pose a danger. A bar owner may also have a duty to clean up spills before someone slips and falls, ensure that the establishment doesn’t serve one guest too much alcohol, and more. Since bar owners have a legal obligation to keep premises safe for patrons, a lot of people wonder if they can sue the bar for injuries that they’ve sustained in a bar fight. If the bar owner knew that this particular assailant who knocked you out had done it several times before, for no reason, the bar owner has an obligation to expel this unsafe person from the bar before they injure anyone else. But if the bar owner had never had an issue with this person before, it would be difficult to claim they had a duty to protect others from them. 

Foreseeability – Bar Fight Lawyer

Legally speaking, foreseeability refers to a person’s ability to anticipate the risks associated with their circumstances. If you know there is a potential for injury, you may have a duty to take reasonable precautions in order to prevent that injury. This is where most bar fight cases have problems. There is not usually a way for a bartender to know when a person is about to begin a bar fight. On busy days like St. Patrick’s Day, it may be impossible for bartenders to constantly monitor all guests in order to prevent the first punch from being thrown. Property owners are not usually responsible for their guests’ injuries if a reasonable person of ordinary prudence couldn’t have foreseen the dangers. However, this is often why bars are cautious not to over-serve patrons.

Personally Suing the Other Party

If the bartender couldn’t have foreseen the bar fight–and that’s usually the case–then you do have another option. Technically, it is possible to sue the other party for causing you injuries.

However, there are two common problems with going this route. First, in order for a lawsuit to be worth your time and effort, the person you’re suing needs to have the assets or money necessary to compensate you for your losses in the event that the case settles, or a judge orders a judgment against the defendant. For this reason, it may be difficult to sue anyone for a bar fight. Furthermore, if the state you’re in allows parties to apportion fault, you may have some fault in the bar fight, making your case even more difficult to win. Because their action of punching your lights out was likely intentional, their homeowners’ insurance won’t likely cover this bad behavior.

In Summary – Bar Fight Lawyer

In many cases, the bar owner’s lack of ability to foresee that a fight is going to break out makes it very difficult to argue that the bar is liable for the patron’s behavior. Furthermore, since it normally takes two people to start a bar fight, both parties may have some liability. In Utah, if you’re more than 49% liable for your damages, you cannot recover for your damages. Even if you were able to sue the patron who started the bar fight, the patron would need to have the ability to pay for your damages. So in most cases, bar fights don’t make strong personal injury claims.

Injured? We Can Help

When you’ve been injured, Moxie Law Group is here for you. We’re Utah’s first female-led personal injury firm dedicated to fighting for the rights of our clients with determination, character, and nerve. If you’ve been injured, and you’re ready to file a claim, contact Moxie Law Group today.

Cup of coffee that is presumably very hot

How Often Do Frivolous Lawsuits Actually Happen

by | Sep 14, 2023 | blog,Educational,Safety,Utah Law | 0 Comments

Hint: it’s much less common than the media would have you thinking.   What Is a Frivolous Lawsuit? When people talk about frivolous lawsuits, they’re normally...

Semi Truck hauling items in fall

Who’s Liable When a Load Isn’t Secure?

by | Sep 12, 2023 | Auto Accidents,blog,Car Accident,Educational,Product Liability | 0 Comments

Picture this: you’re driving down the freeway and there’s a truck in front of you, hauling a bunch of logs. Unfortunately, those logs weren’t tied down correctly, and...

Caution Tape

What Types of Damages Are There?

by | Aug 29, 2023 | Auto Accidents,blog,Car Accident,car accident attorney Utah | 0 Comments

If you're wondering what types of damages there are, Moxie Law Group is here to explain. In the most simple terms, damages refer to the cost of your injuries and...

Spa products in a relaxing environment

At-Home Spa Safety

by | Aug 25, 2023 | blog,Educational,Safety,Texas Law,Utah Law | 0 Comments

Prices continue to go up. Just ten years ago you may have been able to get your eyebrows waxed, hair cut, and nails done for around $100. In 2023, the average price of...

Wondering what last clear chance doctrine is? Find out more here.

What Is the Last Clear Chance Doctrine?

by | Aug 25, 2023 | Auto Accidents,blog,Car Accident,car accident attorney Utah,Educational | 0 Comments

Let’s say you’re driving down the street and a guy pulls out in front of you. Instead of slamming on your brakes, you decide to teach him a lesson and continue going at...

Poolside with a hat next to it

Attractive Nuisance Doctrine and Swimming Pools

by | Aug 22, 2023 | blog,Educational,Texas Law,Utah Law,Utah personal injury | 0 Comments

If you’ve got a pool in your backyard, you’ve likely got a bunch of fun plans this summer, and they very unlikely include meeting with an attorney, or frantically...

Getting Ready for Motorcycle Season

Getting Ready for Motorcycle Season

by | Aug 17, 2023 | Auto Accidents,blog,Motorcycle Accident,Personal Injury Attorney Utah,Personal Injury Lawyer Utah,Safety,Texas Law,Utah Law,Utah Personal Injury Lawyer | 0 Comments

If you’ve spent any amount of time on the road these past few weeks, you’ve probably heard the familiar buzzing sound of a motorcycle coming up behind you. That’s...

truck accident lawyer in Utah

How to Prevent Truck Accidents

by | Aug 10, 2023 | Auto Accidents,Car Accident,car accident attorney Utah,Catastrophic Injuries,Personal Injury Attorney Utah,Personal injury attorneys Utah,Personal Injury Lawyer Utah,Truck accident lawyer,Utah Law,Utah personal injury,Utah personal injury attorney,Utah Personal Injury Lawyer | 0 Comments

Nobody likes being stuck behind a semi-truck driver, but it’s always important to take proactive measures to keep yourself, and others on the road safe.  Be Considerate...

How to Get Compensation for Household Services

How to Get Compensation for Household Services

by | Aug 3, 2023 | blog,Educational,Premises Liability,Safety,Utah Law | 0 Comments

A lot of people haven’t been told about all the benefits they are eligible to receive after they’ve sustained injury due to another person’s negligence. Most people...