When Your Doctor Gives You COVID

ELI5: Negligence

When Your Doctor Gives You COVID

Since the Supreme Court ruling that allowed healthcare facilities to mandate employee vaccinations, an increasing number of medical professionals have resigned, seeking work in places that do not require them to receive the vaccine. One of the unintentional consequences of requiring employees of healthcare facilities to get vaccinated is that these facilities are now short-staffed. In order to combat the issues that understaffing has caused, Health officials have allowed medical professionals who have tested positive and have the COVID virus to continue to come to work. Many people are now wondering, if a person catches COVID from their doctor, is it medical malpractice?


Medical professionals are held to a different standard than your average person, called the “standard of care.” Successful medical malpractice claims have the following elements: the medical professional had a duty of care, the duty of care was breached, the patient was injured, and the injury was a direct result of the breach of care. Proving that a medical professional had a duty of care is the easy part because there is a clearly established relationship between the medical professional and their patient. Proving the duty of care was breached is a different story. In order to prove that there was a breach of duty, the medical professional’s conduct is held up against the conduct of other medical professionals with similar credentials. This means a neurosurgeon’s actions will be measured against the actions of another neurosurgeon.


Clearly, a medical professional has breached their duty of care when they come to work with a deadly and contagious disease. But, in the case of the COVID-19 pandemic, it’s not that simple because the standard of care has changed, at least temporarily, due to the circumstances. If a person is choking to death in a restaurant, and a doctor happens to be in the restaurant and is able to save the person’s life with a ballpoint pen tracheotomy, have they violated the standard of care? Certainly, we wouldn’t dream of using a makeshift ballpoint pen tracheotomy in a hospital. However, at a restaurant, under the circumstances, the standard of care is a little different because the doctor did not have access to the appropriate equipment. Because there is such a large shortage of nurses, authorities have decided that the risks of having nurses infected with COVID don’t outweigh the benefits of having a full staff. Just like the doctor in the restaurant decided, the risks of performing a ballpoint pen tracheotomy outweigh the patient’s death.


When Your Doctor Gives You COVID

It would be pretty difficult to sue a medical professional—or anyone else for that matter—for giving you COVID-19. This is because you would have to prove that it’s more likely than not that the medical professional, and nobody else, gave you the virus. Although it sounds pretty simple, a lot of people are surprised at how difficult it is to prove that it’s more likely than not that the medical professional gave you COVID. The reason this is such a struggle has to do with the fact that patients have contact with so many different people, it’s difficult to be certain who gave the patient the virus–especially with asymptomatic cases. 


A lot of people are wondering if there’s any way they can sue the officials who allowed medical professionals infected with COVID to come to work. However, it can be difficult to sue governmental agencies because of governmental immunity. Governmental immunity protects the government and its agencies from lawsuits. Though it can be waived, it’s typically only waived in specific circumstances. So, if the officials who decided that healthcare workers with COVID could come to work were governmental agencies, it would be difficult to sue them. Also, they likely decided that it was better to expose patients to COVID than leave them unattended due to the shortage of healthcare workers.


When Your Doctor Gives You COVID

A lot of people wonder why we aren’t just bringing back the unvaccinated nurses who don’t have COVID and allowing them to work. Though this may fix the shortage, it may no longer be possible to allow them to come back to work unvaccinated. Part of the Supreme Court’s ruling allowed the mandate that, at certain facilities, employees be required to be vaccinated. Any facility that receives funds from Medicare or Medicaid needs to mandate that all of their employees receive the vaccine. Since most healthcare facilities receive funds from medicare or Medicaid, most medical professionals are subject to this ruling. Therefore, simply bringing back all the unvaccinated healthcare workers may no longer be an option since the Supreme Court has upheld the Secretary of Health and Human Services’ authority to require healthcare employees to get vaccinated.


Though we probably cannot help you sue the person who gave you COVID-19, Moxie Law Group does have expertise in the medical field. Our talented team members are experts in handling medical malpractice cases. We can help you win the compensation you deserve after you’ve been injured by a negligent doctor. If you’re ready to file your case, contact Moxie Law Group today.

Cup of coffee that is presumably very hot

How Often Do Frivolous Lawsuits Actually Happen

by | Sep 14, 2023 | blog,Educational,Safety,Utah Law | 0 Comments

Hint: it’s much less common than the media would have you thinking.   What Is a Frivolous Lawsuit? When people talk about frivolous lawsuits, they’re normally...

Semi Truck hauling items in fall

Who’s Liable When a Load Isn’t Secure?

by | Sep 12, 2023 | Auto Accidents,blog,Car Accident,Educational,Product Liability | 0 Comments

Picture this: you’re driving down the freeway and there’s a truck in front of you, hauling a bunch of logs. Unfortunately, those logs weren’t tied down correctly, and...

Caution Tape

What Types of Damages Are There?

by | Aug 29, 2023 | Auto Accidents,blog,Car Accident,car accident attorney Utah | 0 Comments

If you're wondering what types of damages there are, Moxie Law Group is here to explain. In the most simple terms, damages refer to the cost of your injuries and...

Spa products in a relaxing environment

At-Home Spa Safety

by | Aug 25, 2023 | blog,Educational,Safety,Texas Law,Utah Law | 0 Comments

Prices continue to go up. Just ten years ago you may have been able to get your eyebrows waxed, hair cut, and nails done for around $100. In 2023, the average price of...

Wondering what last clear chance doctrine is? Find out more here.

What Is the Last Clear Chance Doctrine?

by | Aug 25, 2023 | Auto Accidents,blog,Car Accident,car accident attorney Utah,Educational | 0 Comments

Let’s say you’re driving down the street and a guy pulls out in front of you. Instead of slamming on your brakes, you decide to teach him a lesson and continue going at...

Poolside with a hat next to it

Attractive Nuisance Doctrine and Swimming Pools

by | Aug 22, 2023 | blog,Educational,Texas Law,Utah Law,Utah personal injury | 0 Comments

If you’ve got a pool in your backyard, you’ve likely got a bunch of fun plans this summer, and they very unlikely include meeting with an attorney, or frantically...

Getting Ready for Motorcycle Season

Getting Ready for Motorcycle Season

by | Aug 17, 2023 | Auto Accidents,blog,Motorcycle Accident,Personal Injury Attorney Utah,Personal Injury Lawyer Utah,Safety,Texas Law,Utah Law,Utah Personal Injury Lawyer | 0 Comments

If you’ve spent any amount of time on the road these past few weeks, you’ve probably heard the familiar buzzing sound of a motorcycle coming up behind you. That’s...

truck accident lawyer in Utah

How to Prevent Truck Accidents

by | Aug 10, 2023 | Auto Accidents,Car Accident,car accident attorney Utah,Catastrophic Injuries,Personal Injury Attorney Utah,Personal injury attorneys Utah,Personal Injury Lawyer Utah,Truck accident lawyer,Utah Law,Utah personal injury,Utah personal injury attorney,Utah Personal Injury Lawyer | 0 Comments

Nobody likes being stuck behind a semi-truck driver, but it’s always important to take proactive measures to keep yourself, and others on the road safe.  Be Considerate...

How to Get Compensation for Household Services

How to Get Compensation for Household Services

by | Aug 3, 2023 | blog,Educational,Premises Liability,Safety,Utah Law | 0 Comments

A lot of people haven’t been told about all the benefits they are eligible to receive after they’ve sustained injury due to another person’s negligence. Most people...